The prevailing Republican explanation for our recent, and entirely predictable electoral annihilation is not that the president is terribly unpopular, nor that Congress has failed to address virtually any of the pressing problems facing Americans, but that voters are suffering from Iran War fatigue. Besides, we are assured the president’s party ordinarily loses ground in midterm elections. Nothing to see here. Just the familiar pendulum of American politics swinging back in the other direction.
Except we didn’t merely give back ground. We gave back the Senate, the House, and, for goodness’ sake, even Texas, South Carolina, and Mississippi! This was no ordinary reversion to the mean. If anything, I suspect it was a rejection of the politics of mean and the dreariness that accompanies it. And that is precisely what Republicans seem determined not to understand.
I’ve listed the political reasons for our defeat in a prior essay, not least of which was the Republican Congress’s failure to address the needs of the American people, and yes, the War in Iran and the fatigue Americans must feel from it. But the greater war fatigue is culture war fatigue, and I suggest that this is the overarching reason for the Republican defeat, for this infects all other issues and how voters feel about the country and its direction. We don’t want to keep a party in power when the country feels sick. And we are sick; sick and tired of the relentless hostility toward one another, and the insistence that every disagreement must become a moral crusade. We are tired of being told whom to hate, of being hated ourselves, and of seeing our fellow Americans divided into loyalists and enemies. Differences of opinion on taxation, immigration, or social policy are no longer treated as honest disagreements among reasonable people, but as evidence of moral depravity. Our political adversaries are no longer mistaken, differently informed, or simply entitled to their own opinions. They are wicked. And because they are all wicked, no insult is too cruel, no accusation too extravagant, and no reconciliation possible.
But the problem runs deeper than our growing contempt for political adversaries. It is that we have increasingly come to regard practically everyone as a political adversary. Our neighbors, colleagues, friends, and even relatives have become potential antagonists in an ideological struggle from which no relationship is entirely exempt. A disagreement that once might have been forgotten over dinner, if it were even mentioned, can now become grounds for estrangement. We have transformed ordinary human relationships into political associations, measuring the worth of people we have known for decades against the ideological orthodoxies of the moment. We both despise and feel despised, suspect and feel suspected. Who wants to live like this?
Conservatives once understood that politics was supposed to be downstream of culture. Today, the relationship has been almost entirely reversed. Politics has become so omnipresent, so intrusive, and so emotionally demanding that it has colonized practically every corner of American life. Our entertainment, friendships, workplaces, and family relationships have become battlegrounds in a conflict that never ends, and we the combatants. We can scarcely enjoy a football game or purchase a cup of coffee without being invited to take sides in some ideological controversy. Everything has become political, which is another way of saying that increasingly little is permitted to remain personal and healthy.
This is not supposed to be. One of the great virtues of representative government is that ordinary citizens need not become professional politicians themselves. We elect representatives precisely because the business of governing is sufficiently demanding, contentious, and frequently unpleasant that we entrust it to people who have chosen to make it their temporary vocation. Our responsibility is to remain informed, engage in vigorous debate, participate in elections, and hold those representatives accountable. It is not to spend our lives immersed in the petty antagonisms and misery of partisan combat. Yet somewhere along the way, the political class managed to conscript the entire electorate into its quarrels. The ugliness of politics has become a national pastime. We elected representatives to fight our political battles, only to find ourselves doing the fighting for them. The politicians remain the professionals, but we have all become the pugilists.
Conservatives are certainly not alone in this and we did not start it, but we are supposed to know better. Ours is a philosophy of limited government, individual liberty, and a flourishing civil society. We are supposed to believe that the most important things in life happen not in Washington, but in our homes, churches, neighborhoods, businesses, and voluntary associations. Yet we have become like the Left, having increasingly allowed politics to become the organizing principle of our identities, demanding an emotional allegiance that would once have seemed positively unhealthy. We complain about the politicization of everything while enthusiastically participating in it. The party of limited government has somehow joined the movement of unlimited politics.
Donald Trump did not invent this phenomenon, but having perfected its exploitation, he has become its personification, with the servile Republican Party serving as his instrument. His belligerence was initially refreshing to millions of Americans who had grown weary of the artificial courtesies and rehearsed platitudes of professional politicians who seemed all too content to preside over the country’s decline. Here, at last, was someone willing to say what others would not, to mock the sanctimonious, and to dispense with the tedious conventions of political respectability. There was something undeniably entertaining about watching him puncture the pretensions of people who had spent decades taking themselves far too seriously while ordinary Americans struggled to get ahead.
But there is an enormous difference between occasionally enjoying a good political barb and living under a president who seems constitutionally incapable of refraining from one. What begins as entertaining irreverence eventually becomes exhausting unpleasantness, and the contempt that initially delighted his supporters cannot forever remain confined to their preferred targets. The joke gets old, particularly when the audience finds itself among its subjects. A president who appears determined to antagonize everyone outside his circle of loyalists may delight his most devoted followers, but he also ensures that much of the country spends its days feeling perpetually under attack. This, in turn, provokes counterattacks form the other side, which scarcely needs provocation in the first place, and contributes to the widespread discontent we see today.
Americans, whatever our faults, are generally a decent and agreeable people. We want to get along with our neighbors, enjoy our families, pursue our ambitions, and go about our lives without being conscripted into somebody else’s political crusade. We want to feel good about ourselves and communities. We do not ordinarily wake up looking for enemies. Yet modern politics seems determined to manufacture them for us, and then demands that we devote ourselves to fighting them.
This may help explain something Republicans have consistently misunderstood about Joe Biden’s victory in 2020. Whatever his considerable deficiencies as president, Biden offered voters a return to calm. Americans were not necessarily clamoring for a sweeping progressive transformation of society. Many simply wanted a president who would stop occupying so much of their emotional lives. They were willing, perhaps, to tolerate policies they disliked in exchange for a president they did not have to think about every waking hour. They wanted politics to become boring again, which, in a healthy republic, ought not to be considered an unreasonable aspiration. Whether Biden ultimately delivered on that promise is beside the point. The fact that he could campaign successfully on it should have taught Republicans something.
I cannot tell you how many voters cast their ballots principally out of exhaustion with our political culture. Voters themselves cannot always articulate precisely why they are unhappy. But they are seldom confused about whether they are. And whatever explanations Republican leaders may offer for their defeat, an electoral repudiation of such historic proportions is unmistakable evidence of profound public dissatisfaction. Here, perhaps, we encounter the final irony of the politics of perpetual grievance: the very belligerence that once propelled a movement to power eventually becomes the weight that drags it down. It is the fatal consequence of a Faustian bargain in which political success is purchased at the expense of the public’s goodwill. What initially electrifies an electorate eventually exhausts it, and what once made a politician irresistible ultimately makes him intolerable.
I am increasingly convinced that Republican leaders cannot recognize the phenomenon because they have become so thoroughly immersed in the culture of perpetual conflict themselves. I’ve argued before that these elections did not represent a rejection of conservative principles. Indeed, it would be nice if Republicans actually tried governing according to those principles, or even governing at all. What voters may instead be rejecting is the combination of a party that accomplishes next to nothing while the country remains in a constant state of ideological mobilization. It is an exhausting bargain: all the rancor of political combat, with remarkably few of the rewards of political victory.
The tragedy is that none of this is necessary. Political disagreement is inevitable in a free society, but mutual contempt is not. Indeed, the genius of constitutional republicanism is not that citizens agree upon the good life, but that people who profoundly disagree can nevertheless live together under a common political framework. Our system does not require us to approve of one another’s beliefs. It requires us to recognize one another’s legitimacy as fellow citizens. Once that distinction disappears, political competition ceases to be an ordinary feature of self-government and becomes an existential struggle in which any means of defeating the opposition can be justified.
Conservatism, properly understood, ought to offer an antidote to this condition. A philosophy that prizes liberty, personal responsibility, and the institutions of civil society should understand that a nation’s health cannot be measured solely by its political victories. A civilization cannot flourish when its citizens regard one another with permanent suspicion, nor can liberty endure where the habits of mutual toleration and civic responsibility have been abandoned. We do not preserve a free society merely by defeating those with whom we disagree. We preserve it by maintaining a society in which disagreement remains possible without destroying the bonds that unite us.
Perhaps the next great American political leader will not be the one who promises to fight our enemies more ferociously, but the one who reminds us that our fellow Americans are not our enemies at all. And perhaps the first party to recognize that distinction will discover that the electorate has not grown weary of politics because it cares too little about America, but because it cares too much about the country to spend another decade watching Americans tear one another apart.
We can always hope.











